By Melissa Blasek
Contributing Writer
Donna McElroy has toured as a background singer for Amy Grant, Garth Brooks, Kenny Rogers, and Crystal Gayle. As an arranger/background vocalist she worked on the platinum hits “Why Haven’t I Heard From You?” by Reba McIntyre, “We Shall Be Free” by Garth Brooks, and “House of Love” by Amy Grant. Her solo album, Bigger World with Warner Brothers, was nominated for a Grammy and in 1993 she was awarded Best Actress for her lead role in “Nunsense” by the Circle Players. Today she is a Professor of Voice at Berklee College of Music
MB: Fly To Forever is comprised of your original jazz compositions. What’s your writing process?
DE: It takes several different forms. I’ll come up with all the lyrics, melody, and I’ll think about what the chords should be- but since I’m not a harmonist, I can only come up with the bass. Then I’ll sit down with someone who will fill that in. The other way I’ll write is I’ll sit down with my very rudimentary chord skills, and write a song that is very nice and pleasant sounding. I write really well for myself when I write a little pop number. Then the third way I write is someone will give me a track and say, “Listen to this and if you want to write some lyrics or melody, you do that.”
MB: As far as selecting covers to perform, what makes a song special enough for you to sing it?
DE: Well I try to steer away from the word “cover” because when I think of a cover, I think of a hit that’s current and on the radio, and when you get up there to sing it, it better be as close to the original as possible or don’t even come. I sing standards though. I look for a song that has a lyric that I can relate to personality-wise, or a song where the melody and the harmony are so intricate that it’s exciting for me to say, “I can sing that song!” Or I’ll have a specific composer’s work that I really like and I’ll look for obscure tunes by that person.
MB: You had a run as a solo recording artist in the late 80s. What did you take from the experience?
DE: The most important thing I took is to have a plan because I did not have a plan. Have a style you want to sing in and be comfortable with it because if your record hits, even if it doesn’t, you will be singing that style. My mistake was that I didn’t pick a style. My CD said, “Look how versatile I am!” [The record label] tried to advise me. They said, “We cannot market this record.” But I was thirty-two and you couldn’t tell me anything. I had been out on the road, I had sung on many records, and I had done a ton of jingles. I didn’t understand at all what was expected of me as an artist because all the years I’d been singing background. I was only looking at the concert end of the artists I was singing with. I wasn’t examining the records and song choices. Naturally, on the road, one gets the opportunity to stretch and do lots of different styles if he or she wants to. But you gotta have the band and singers to support those directions. I was part of bands that were all great and versatile musicians. But those musicians weren’t always used on the album/cd, and the album/cd was usually a group of songs which all sounded pretty close to the singles which were released to sell the project. I came into the artist realm not understanding this, and a little too arrogant for my own good, so when they signed me I told them, “You pulled me away from my gig where I was making a lot of money. I did not ask for you to sign me. I expect that you will supplement my income.”
MB: You spent years touring as a background singer for such stars as Amy Grant and Garth Brooks. What’s the hardest aspect of being on the road?
DE: There was nothing hard about being on the road. I liked the travel, the food, and the hotels. Even when I first started out with Amy [Grant], we would get two rooms at a Motel 6, one for the girls in the band and one for the guys in the band, and we would just wash up and then pile back on the bus. And then her records started to do well and by the time I left her we were staying at the Four Seasons and I had a room for myself. I liked it and I liked the luxury of it.
MB: What was the most difficult aspect of dealing with the business end of the music industry?
DE: For me it was not understanding what the record industry was. The first question [the record company] asked me was, “Who is your demographic?” I did not know what the word “demographic” meant. I was like, “I’m singing to everyone!” The fact that I did not understand how the industry worked, worked to [the record company’s] advantage. They will sign you, spend a shit load of money on you, use it as a tax write off, and then shelve your record. You will sit around for years wondering what you did wrong. But you didn’t do anything wrong, you just didn’t know what to do in the first place. You’re being moved around, as an artist, like a pawn on a chessboard.
MB: What advice would give a singer looking to enter the recording industry?
DE: My advice would be to take my recording lab to get the technical end of the job under your belt. Then learn as much about Internet technology as possible. Do it yourself. If you do it yourself and you never get the major deal, you are still your own person, you still have your natural breasts (chuckle), your privacy has not been invaded, and you are a decent person. You’re not as rich, but you can still have a fan base, work with great musicians, and develop yourself as a songwriter. You can just be responsible for representing you and your music and not getting up on that stage and representing so many other people.
















